When Dragonetti first posted about leaving the guild I had prepared a long post about guild loyalty, yackity, smackity, bla, bla, bla. Then before I hit submit I thought to myself that it isn't about loyalty to a tag, it's about loyalty to the people you play with. I guess I knew that I wasn't really going to be playing WoW anymore - due to events it just wasn't fun anymore. But, if the choice was between losing some good friends (Dragonetti, Hama, Rapture) over some B.S. or going with them then I would go with them - even if it was merely a show of support.
I am sorry that everyone is not completely happy where they are but the way I see it, you won't be happy as long as you are playing with people you really don't know. You can't put strangers together and expect them to get along. You are always going to have the know-it-all's, the 'leadership' demanding respect & obedience from their subordinates or those that just use you to get what they want/need. If this can occur among a group of friends then it is many times more likely to occur in a group of strangers. I know that things just aren't the same in WoW but to me they feel like the good old days in SWG. Shoot, even Lockbaka logged on to SWG yesterday!